Meat hunting vs. Trophy hunting

CrimsonArrow

Very Active Member
Feb 21, 2011
857
363
Minnesota
I am a meat hunter to the bone. That's how I was raised, probably because there were so few trophy bucks around home. But I'm not against trophy hunting, as long as the meat is treated with more respect than the antlers/horns. When I'm hunting an area known to have trophy animals, I will hold out for a big buck/bull til the end of the hunt, but you better believe I will fill that tag with any legal animal if possible before I go home. Our family loves the meat and you won't find any red meat in our freezer that's not wild game.
 

norcalhunter

Member
Mar 29, 2011
94
0
Nor Cal
I love to hunt and I enjoy eating the animals I kill. Most of the deer I kill are trophies in my eyes but probably not to others. To sum it up I am a trophy hunter day 1-4 and a meathunter on day 5-6. But like a lot of hunters I would be lying if I said I hunted to feed my family. An out of state deer hunt with the price of a tag and fuel would be $1500, thats alot of ribeyes. The adventure and the dreams of killing that big one keep me coming back.
 

Old Hunter

Banned
Dec 28, 2011
1,104
0
Buena Vista, Co.
Some might get the wrong impression of a meat hunter. Well, at least some of us. I think some think that meat hunters just go out, and shoot the first animal they see, and that's that. Maybe some hunters do that, and that's fine for them.

I can only speak for myself. I prepare for a hunt just like a trophy hunter. I scout over 200 days a year. I get just as excited about the hunt as anybody. I never have to set the alarm, because i'm wide awake at 2am ready to go. I choose what I believe is the most difficult way to hunt, and i'm very choosy what I shoot, and how I shoot it. I pass on way way more animals than I shoot at. What gets me excited is the hunt itself. It's not the pulling of the trigger. It's what leads up to it. I shoot plenty of trophy animals, but I do it for different reasons. I do it for the challenge, and the meat. The rack is not important, except that I know it's a mature animal that is smart enough to live long enough to grow it.

The hunt is everything. Not the kill.
 

Fink

Veteran member
Apr 7, 2011
1,961
204
West Side, MoMo
I think that the whole trophy hunter vs meat hunter drives a bigger stake in our little community than does any other argument.

I'm a trophy hunter. That said, my trophy might not meet the same definition of someone else's trophy. A bull elk or a mulie buck that I might shoot, might make some Western Guru cringe, but at the same time, I'll let big whitetails walk all day long, and won't fill a whitetail buck tag three years out of four. I'll shoot a doe every now and again, because I really do enjoy the meat, but I'm not going to shoot a little buck just to eat, I enjoy hunting big deer far too much to end my season early.

I WILL NOT shoot hen ducks though, does this make me an elitist trophy duck hunter?
 

norcalhunter

Member
Mar 29, 2011
94
0
Nor Cal
Trophy hunter vs. Meat hunters
Rifle hunters vs. Archery hunters
Compound bow vs. Traditional bow
Long range vs. short range
I am just a hunter, why label myself.
 

Musket Man

Veteran member
Jul 20, 2011
6,457
0
colfax, wa
I have tried hunting does a couple times but honestly I have a hard time getting very excited about it. I do really like all wild game meat and I pretty much live on it. I bought a leftover doe antelope tag for this year to get some more meat since antelope might be my only hunt this year but its kinda hard for me to kill does because I dont like killing any animal Im not excited about killing.
 

Ilovethewest

Active Member
Jul 11, 2012
169
0
Wisconsin
the trophy hunting thing is 10x worse here in WI than it is out west. Land gets bought up an locked down. Guys passing on 160" deer b/c they are not "big enough" to shoot. Neighbors fighting b/c someone shoots one of the "marginal" 140"-150" bucks that could grow into a "shooter" someday. Trail cameras getting stolen.................no, you guys have it good compared to the idiocy here in WI. Hunting in WI is dang near ruined unless you own land. And even then, the big buck craze has family member against family member......it truly is insane. I hunt public land in WI, and see few if any deer in an entire season. That being said, we usually shoot good bucks. I wont shoot does b/c the public lands are so devoid of deer due to 10 years of Earn a Buck regulations. So typically the deer I do see tend to be good bucks.

That is why I love hunting out west. 3 weeks from today I will be headed to Gillette. Cant wait. I will hunt for a good buck out there, but I wont hesitate on a decent buck later in the hunt, if the stalk is good and the hunt was a good one. I have eaten tag soup before when I could have tagged out on a small forkie.

So I am not sure what I am. I don't fit in around here in Wisconsin in the Big Buck insanity..........but I am not brown is down hunter either. I guess I am one of a kind!

P.S - yes I have strong feelings on Wisconsin hunting. mostly, my opinions are negative due to lack of land access, few deer on public lands, and private land owners hording deer. and our DNR are insane too. wackos. The only good thing is that Fall in Wisconsin is beautiful!
 

Old Hunter

Banned
Dec 28, 2011
1,104
0
Buena Vista, Co.
Whether you're a trophy hunter, meat hunter, or something in between. The most important thing is to enjoy every minute of the hunt.

Nothing is better than hunting.
 

BobT

Active Member
Dec 1, 2011
263
0
Missouri Ozarks
Trophy is in the eye of the beholder.
Well said!

Every animal I kill is a trophy to me. I guess I could be called a trophy hunter by some folks, I simply try to kill older animals if I can. I do have a few heads on the wall but they are in my office or bedroom and not on display in the rooms company commonly frequent with the exception of a pronghorn skull my wife likes on the living room wall. I keep the horns/antlers and mount or otherwise preserve them not for something to brag about but more like a tribute to the animal or as a reminder of the hunt. I also have a lot of family members who love game meat but don't hunt so I share with them. If i'm hunting strictly for meat I try to find an old doe. I tend to let a lot of young animals walk away. Most of the "professional hunters" make me sick, they are not hunters at all in my book, simply shooters. Some of them are just clowns who I doubt could even find a deer on public land let alone kill it. They just pay someone else to do their hunting for them. I really think it's a personal decision that each of us must make and live with. If someone wants to only shoot large specimens that's fine by me, as long as the meat is put to good use I don't have a problem with it.
 

CrimsonArrow

Very Active Member
Feb 21, 2011
857
363
Minnesota
I have tried hunting does a couple times but honestly I have a hard time getting very excited about it. I do really like all wild game meat and I pretty much live on it. I bought a leftover doe antelope tag for this year to get some more meat since antelope might be my only hunt this year but its kinda hard for me to kill does because I dont like killing any animal Im not excited about killing.
Last weekend was our archery opener, and on Sunday morning, I killed a yearling doe. I didn't enjoy killing her, and never enjoy taking a life. In fact, sometimes I get sad after killing a deer, even though the only reason for killing it was for meat. Killing never makes me sad enough to become a vegetarian, though. I am a meat eater, that's just the way it is. It's in my DNA. An added bonus is I was able to hunt this deer 300 yards from my house on public land, so for a $14 management tag, I put 40 lbs of tasty meat in my freezer.
 

ando_31

Active Member
Sep 14, 2012
402
0
ND
Its all in the hunt. Not the kill, not the kitchen, not the photos. I can't say that I've eaten everything I've shot (prairie dogs, coyotes, fox, ect.), but I can say I've made use of the animals I consider edible and believe everyone else should as well. Like every other ethical dilemma when hunting, there seems to me a wide variance in what is considered the minimal acceptable use of an animal. Its obvious we all fit somewhere in the middle of the Native Americans who used every usable part of an animal and the buffalo hunters of the past who wasted almost everything. Wild game doesn't tickle my taste buds as a beef ribeye would, but there is much more of a sense of accomplishment and an ease of mind knowing that the skill to provide still lives on with each bite of a wild animal.

There is a sort of compassion that accompanies me to the field. I find it difficult to pull the trigger on uneducated deer. If my goal were to simply fill my tag every year I have no doubt I could do so in a quick manner. The hunt to me is a reason to get out and be part of nature. I have many tags end up in the garbage and that is okay with me because all that means is that I got to hunt the whole season. I consider all the close encounters with young animals to be practice for when or if the time comes when I will have to use this skill in a practical manner. To know I have taken a mature and wary animal simply means I am simply on top of my game as far as hunting skills are concerned.

There are many different opinionated people on this site. The difference from this site to the next is that most of the discussions are healthy, peaceful, and honest and can in fact change the opinions of its readers or at least help some shed some light on why some hunters are the way they are. I enjoyed reading this thread and am encouraged with the enthusiasm it shows. It shows that, all of us are passionate about our....lets call it heritage instead of a sport.
 

shootbrownelk

Veteran member
Apr 11, 2011
1,535
196
Wyoming
the trophy hunting thing is 10x worse here in WI than it is out west. Land gets bought up an locked down. Guys passing on 160" deer b/c they are not "big enough" to shoot. Neighbors fighting b/c someone shoots one of the "marginal" 140"-150" bucks that could grow into a "shooter" someday. Trail cameras getting stolen.................no, you guys have it good compared to the idiocy here in WI. Hunting in WI is dang near ruined unless you own land. And even then, the big buck craze has family member against family member......it truly is insane. I hunt public land in WI, and see few if any deer in an entire season. That being said, we usually shoot good bucks. I wont shoot does b/c the public lands are so devoid of deer due to 10 years of Earn a Buck regulations. So typically the deer I do see tend to be good bucks.

That is why I love hunting out west. 3 weeks from today I will be headed to Gillette. Cant wait. I will hunt for a good buck out there, but I wont hesitate on a decent buck later in the hunt, if the stalk is good and the hunt was a good one. I have eaten tag soup before when I could have tagged out on a small forkie.

So I am not sure what I am. I don't fit in around here in Wisconsin in the Big Buck insanity..........but I am not brown is down hunter either. I guess I am one of a kind!

P.S - yes I have strong feelings on Wisconsin hunting. mostly, my opinions are negative due to lack of land access, few deer on public lands, and private land owners hording deer. and our DNR are insane too. wackos. The only good thing is that Fall in Wisconsin is beautiful!
ILTW, I hear you. I have relatives that live in Wisconsin. They tell me basically what you said. Trophy Deer Management run amok.
A lot of hunters back there also quit hunting altogether because of personal trophy deer farms. Pretty sad.
 

Ikeepitcold

Administrator
Staff member
Feb 22, 2011
10,022
1,609
Reno Nv
This is a Wisconsin calico buck. Cabelas paid this guy $13,000 for the cape and horns. Thought it would be appropriate with all the talk about WI. I think this guy would consider himself a trophy hunter.

 

Musket Man

Veteran member
Jul 20, 2011
6,457
0
colfax, wa
I think most hunters weather they are trophy hunters, meat hunters or somewhere in between are good hunters with good ethics. There are just a few trophy hunters that all all they care about is killing the biggest buck or bull they can and dont care about anything else or how much it costs, and a few meat hunters that all they care about is killing something no matter what, and they give both a bad image. Its just horrible here where I live. Its mostly open farm fields and opening morning there are pickups and 4 wheelers chasing deer all over. Some of them dont even know whose property they are on. If you drive out in a field after 9am opening morning and a deer sees you 1/2 a mile away they are gone on a dead run. I even had a guy shoot in my direction near my house on the border of my property and the neighbors. I dont say his shots werent backed by a hill but the muzzle was still in my direction. I tracked him down and told him he was lucky I didnt return fire as that is the first thing I think of in situations like that. We have lots of whitetails but I dont even hunt around here because of how everyone else hunts.
 

Old Hunter

Banned
Dec 28, 2011
1,104
0
Buena Vista, Co.
I'd like to add one more comment so there's no misunderstanding about me.

I may have strong opinions on hunting methods, but all it means is it's something I wouldn't do. I hold no bias if someone else does it. It also doesn't mean we can't be friends. One of my best friends uses bait, and a tree stand. Of course I rag him about it, but we're still best friends.

There are some who i'd have nothing to do with, but I don't call them hunters, and see none of that on this forum.