Hunting shots you regret passing on...

Umpqua Hunter

Veteran member
May 26, 2011
3,576
88
61
North Umpqua, Oregon
Do you have any opportunities on animals that you passed on and now looking back that decision haunts you. I have two.

The first was back in the 1980's and I was in my early 20s. I had been hunting late muzzleloader blacktail seasons, and my goal that year was a "four point" or nothing, western count (I've since learned not to make goals like that). I ended up passing on a monster, old, reverted, heavy fork horn at....10 YARDS. We bumped into a guy who asked if we saw the big fork horn in the area and that it was the biggest buck he had ever seen. That one still hurts.

The next one was in 2010. My wife had drawn a limited entry Wyoming deer unit in a long shot random draw and it was going to be her first deer hunt. We decided to hunt the last few days of the season. On the first morning it was snowing, perfect conditions. We hadn't had time to scout and I really did not know for certain what the quality we would find on that unit. We ran into a buck chasing some does, one of the first bucks we had seen. He was strangely narrow, I mean strangely narrow, like 14-15" narrow, but he was VERY tall and had deep forks, each tine around 11". I kept asking her if she thought it was a good one, and she kept telling me she didn't know what to look for. We sat on that buck under 100 yards for a solid 5 minutes, what seemed like forever, and he was happy checking out the does. There were many easy shot opportunities at him. Finally I told her to shoot him. As if on cue, he grouped up with some does and for another minute or two he milled around right in the middle of them. They finally got tired of us and trotted off. I recalled that one again this morning after I looked at a set of 190+ sheds and remembered that Wyoming buck with tines in similar class and I still can't believe I was so indecisive, especially on her first buck.

Both of those opportunities would have been chip shots and it just came down to choosing not to shoot.
 

ElkTrout

Veteran member
Feb 2, 2012
2,443
50
Parker, CO
There are always opportunities that I look back on after the fact and think I should have pulled the trigger. But I am also a strong believer that if the shot doesn't feel right at the time then there is a good reason for not taking it! I think when I was younger and not as confident in my abilities there was shots that I would definitely take now without hesitation! But I guess that is just the progression in hunting. Now if we are talking misses, well that's another story! Haha! Plenty of those I regret!


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 

CrossCreeks

Veteran member
Mar 6, 2014
1,023
0
Dover, Tennessee
19 yrs. ago , Colorado on the Grand Mesa, opening morning of Elk season, heard elk bugling and manage to get into position to see the bull bugling and his cows around him just across a small drainage. To this day I still see the breath from his nostrils as he throws his head back and bulges. I thought I was too far and slide down the mountainside to work closer. I heard a shot up the drainage and the elk disappeared. I climbed back up the spot I originally spotted him and after looking around ,realized I could have made the shot. He was a nice 6X6 and would have been my 3rd elk I had taken and one of the biggest. !!
 

Hilltop

Veteran member
Feb 25, 2014
3,848
2,231
Eastern Nebraska
2 years ago hunting Wyoming I passed a shot on a bull that I think would have gone close to 400". I was steady on bi-pods and the bull was quartering away standing still. The problem was my wife couldn't get a range. I had guessed 450 yards but wasn't 100% confident and didn't want to take a chance at a bad shot or miss him and blow the herd out or the drainage. Cows had us pinned down so there was zero chance at closing the gap. I watched the bull walk out of sight at the same time my wife got a range of 470 yards. I know now that I would have cleanly taken the bull. Part of me regrets not taking that shot but I know I made the right decision. I did end up taking a 352" bull later that day- great consolation prize.
 

WY ME

Very Active Member
Feb 4, 2014
549
47
Wyoming
I passed on several big deer back in '94 because I was determined to fill my sheep tag. One buck was 32" with a drop tine. The biggest one was a 35" buck that another hunter killed 2 weeks later and won a big buck contest with it. I never got my ram and I've never killed a big deer. I don't regret the deer but I've had sheepmares for 20 years.
 

JimP

Administrator
Mar 28, 2016
7,322
8,708
72
Gypsum, Co
It is my belief that no passed up shot is a bad idea. You have to figure what is going on at the time and usually your first decision is usually the better one.

Now after saying that...........I had a grizzly bear in a small clearing at 578 yards away while hunting them in British Colombia. i watched that bear for over a hour trying to figure out if I should take the shot or not. Then he was gone. The next day I was sitting in the same spot and a bull elk came into the same clearing and now I had something to judge the size of the bear against and I knew that I could of made that shot the day before. I went home empty handed.

Another one was on a booner class mule deer. I came into a clearing and spotted him a long ways off but well within my capabilities. there was another 4x4 buck standing with him and the big one made the smaller buck look like a fawn. I worked my way to within 70 yards of both deer but could only find the smaller buck which spooked and ran into some other hunters just down the hill from me. He ended up being a very nice 4x4 with a 26" spread, but that bigger buck was the one that I wanted. He was never to be seen again. I came to find out that there was another hunter hunting him and had been after him for 3 seasons that year. The other hunter was a dedicated hunter in Utah and could hunt archery, muzzle loader, and rifle. We both agreed that he was a buck of a lifetime.
 

Rooster410

New Member
Jul 6, 2013
36
1
Utah
I had burned 10 points on an archery elk hunt in Utah, 7 day hunt. I was in and out of the elk, not much rut activity but I was extremely hopeful/encouraged. Day 5 I hiked into a previously unknown basin and immediately spotted 2 shooter bulls bedded about 1 mile down the ridge, facing away from me and into the wind. As I stalked towards them a huge 5x4 buck with a drop and a cheater fed over the ridge right into me within 20 yards. I had the appropriate deer tag. I must of had the fog of the elk rut in my nose and brain because I sat and waited for the buck to feed over the ridge so I didn't push him into the elk (about 10 minutes - eternity). You can guess the result. I was within 150 yds of the bulls when they stood and fed out, not rushed. I could never get closer, cut the distance or cut them off. I ate both tags. I look back and can appreciate the desire and excitement of wanting to tag out on a bruiser first time archery elk, but I was foolish. lesson learned.
 

ivorytip

Veteran member
Mar 24, 2012
3,769
50
44
SE Idaho
nice thread! I had one last fall, I was posted up in a make shift blind watching an elk wallow that was active. I heard a noise to my left and 15 yrds away was a beautiful 180 buck feeding broadside to me, I couldn't believe my luck, I had bought a non res deer tag for something just like this! my bow already had an arrow nocked and was on a kick stand, I slowly picked it up and drew string as I was watching the buck..... just as I was resting pin on his sweet spot he looked up and past me, that's when I seen that his left side was as tiny as my hand and was palmated while his right side was an easy 180 4!!!!!!! I still had all of September and October so I passed. as he walked away I regretted not taking him, would have been a very unique head to have on wall.
 

mallardsx2

Veteran member
Jul 8, 2015
3,938
3,254
I passed up a walking shot on a huge 11 point at 25 yards one year. It still haunts me. But at the end of the day it was the ethical decision to make. And I would have been more upset if I had wounded the deer. Another hunter killed that buck on the first day of rifle season.
 

AT Hiker

Very Active Member
Aug 2, 2012
638
0
Tennessee
I passed on a solid 120" Coues deer last season at 125 yards. It was my first time in AZ and that country had me confused. I thought it was further than it was and I didnt realize he was as big as he was until I seen him again later that day, in which I missed him twice at 300+ yards!




Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 

mntnguide

Very Active Member
12 years ago..first bull tag in my pocket.. opening morning. . Passed a shot at a bull because i was unsure if the cows behind him were in a good spot or not for me to take the shot..Knowing what i know now, the bull was pushing 350, and for the unit in idaho, was a damn good bull. . But though i still think about it all the time, I am still sure I made the right choice in not trying the shot. He disappeared into black timber and I never saw him again as wolves moved into the drainage soon after and blew every elk out of the country
 

hoshour

Veteran member
My first mulie hunt after years of hunting whitetails - early Nov in Colorado. I saw a buck with a swollen neck and big Roman nose laying under a tree 100 yards away across an opening in the woods.

I was in the wide open with just a big rock behind me and very few minutes he would look over my way for a couple minutes, but never made me out. It was really odd, almost like a mechanical deer. All he ever did was move his head one way for a few minutes, then my way for a few.

His rack was in the pine tree and all I could make out was his passenger side front which was decent. I could not see his backs. He was just 30 yards onto private land but it was a fence in the woods and I'm not sure he knew which side was private. The biologist said most of the deer in that season had traveled in.

I watched him for 30 minutes and being a new western hunter and hunting with a first-time deer hunter who was getting antsy, went on my way to find a good buck. No patience!

Now, I look back and think what an idiot I was! Those antlers grow bigger the longer I think about it and I wonder if after a while he didn't just get up and jump that low fence.
 

Ikeepitcold

Administrator
Staff member
Feb 22, 2011
10,034
1,623
Reno Nv
I know I've passed up some shots before but thinking about it I was always able to relocate and get the shot. I would wish over and over again that I would have taken the shot but passed then was able to get the shot in the end.
 

HeartElk1

Active Member
Mar 30, 2011
193
0
Great thread -- really makes you think. About 25 years ago I was in Alaska with a friend on a hunting/fishing trip. We each had moose tags and right away on the first day we spotted a nice bull. My buddy drew the long straw so he was to be first shooter so he took off after the bull and told me to be ready just in case. Sure enough, the bull came right by me and stopped broadside at 50 yards in the small river we were on. Legal bulls needed to be at least 50" wide or have at least 3 brow tines on either side. I just wasn't sure about the brow tines or if he would quite make that 50 inch spread limit but he looked dang nice to me. Very good reason not to shoot though. Also having a dead bull moose in the water would have been a disaster for us 2 rookies. So I let him walk and he ended up being the only bull we saw that trip. I have no regrets because it wouldn't have been ethical to shoot anyway and now I get to let that bull grow even bigger in my imagination!! I also definitely don't regret taking my fishing pole on that trip - the Coho fishing was great.
 

Joe Hulburt

Active Member
Mar 14, 2011
392
1
Oregon Coast
I had what would have been the biggest Rocky Mt Elk I've killed broadside at 24 yards last archery season and I just layed my bow down and took a picture. Wenaha tag in hand with 14 more days to hunt so I didn't really even consider taking the shot. I guess I regret it now since my knee went to heck late in the hunt and I ate the tag. The thing I wonder is if I would of regretted ending my hunt that early more than I regret passing??? I think I made the right call....

I had what I hope to be my final knee surgery this am so I'm laying on my couch with knee up staring at trophy wall at 3:40 am so it's been on my mind...
 

Timberstalker

Veteran member
Feb 1, 2012
2,242
6
Bend, Or
About 20 years ago, it was right at daylight on the third day of Blacktail season. I had zero doubt he was a buck, just couldn't quite tell how big with my naked eye. When I drew down on him I had a glare in my scope from the rising sun, it was right in my eyes. All I had to do was squeeze the trigger and it was over but I wanted to make sure he was big enough, I didn't want to shoot a small buck that early in the season. Well when he turned, he turned fast! He was a really nice buck, big black horns about 18"-20" wide.
 

kidoggy

Veteran member
Apr 23, 2016
9,847
10,860
58
idaho
I've passed on quite a few . some I didn't want to kill and some I did and just didn't feel circumstances were right. I do not feel an ounce of regret for passing on a single one.
perhaps regret I didn't kill them but zero regret for passing the shot. I would rather an animal walked the to make a bad shot.I know I made the right choice, in each and every instance.


perhaps . what is the shot you took, that you regret the most? would also make an interesting thread.
 
Last edited:

Vikingload

Member
Jun 12, 2015
115
0
Powell WY
I passed on a bull that I thought was 350+ here in Wyoming this past year. Steady rest, controlled breathing, and confident in my skills to shoot a 400 yard shot all day long. Didn't shoot because I got a lot of crap for taking a clean 400 yard shot the year before. Haunts me everyday and reminds me to trust my skills not others opinions haha!!


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 

Fink

Veteran member
Apr 7, 2011
1,961
204
West Side, MoMo
I have 2 that really stand out.. 15 years ago on the opening day of rifle season I was hunting a stand that I had been hunting quite a bit for the last 2 weeks, and was seeing bunches of deer every day.. This morning, I saw no deer, and at noon was considering going back to the cabin for lunch and to regroup. Suddenly, the woods was alive, and a bunch of does poured out of the thicket, into the open oaks,right in front of me. Right behind them was easily the biggest buck I've ever seen on stand, and one of the biggest deer I've ever seen period. He was an easy 180, and probably a 190, but I can't be certain. He came out of the thick stuff 10 yards in front of my stand, and immediately turned directly away from me walking. I put the crosshairs in between his shoulder blades..... And didn't pull the trigger. I don't know why. As soon as he crested the hill about 75 yards away, I came out of my funk, and realized what I had done. I climbed down the first two steps of my stand, and the just jumped the rest of the way down and ran after him. Of course, he was gone. that was horrible. For probably 10 years, I got the shakes just thinking about it.

The second was on my first elk hunt in Wyoming. I had hunted for 7 days, and not had an opportunity. Finally, on the 8th day, the bulls bugled all morning, and bedded down way above me. I went around, and got on an even elevation with them, and started my stalk. There was a guide with a hunter about 1000 feet in elevation below me, bugling often, and working his way up to the elk. Every time he bugled, it would start a new round of bugling, allowing me to really hone in on where the bulls were. I had finally stalked to within 20 yards or so, but could barely see the bull through all the thick stuff. Finally, the bull gets out of his bed, and walks towards an opening. I can see that he's a nice 6 point, and I draw my bow. He comes into the clearing, and it's a quartering away 20 feet above him shot. I'm in awe of how big his body is. These elk are way bigger than whitetails. In the instant he walks through the opening, I'm thinking that I really want a perfect broadside shot, and also, this elk is a really big animal. He walks through the opening, and the opportunity is gone. I didnt shoot. The wind is blowing from them to me, so I wait, hoping for a new opportunity. Unfortunately, the wind is blowing from the guide to the elk, and they soon blow completely out of the drainage, right by me. Depression.
 

packmule

Veteran member
Jun 21, 2011
2,433
0
TX
I've let several deer walk off that I probably should've shot. Sometimes I'm just too picky or get fixated on 1 deer.