best broadhead for elk
- Thread starter gator7275
- Start date
BOHNTR
Very Active Member
There is no "best" broadhead for elk........the one you're using (MX3) will make an elk just as "dead" as any other out there. Just make sure whatever head you use flies well with solid construction and you'll be fine......MX3 is exactly that, IMO.
Big Sky
Active Member
Seconded. The others work for a lot of people but I think about my gear too much to have something that is just 'good enough'.
sjsmallfield
Veteran member
brandenbowhunter
Member
I love the Simmons sharks broadheads...pass throughs with this head at some pretty long range shots...I love them...
www.simmomssharks.com
www.simmomssharks.com
tommyp
Active Member
Bitterroot Bulls
Veteran member
I shoot slick tricks, but mostly because they shoot really tight, and I don't have any POI change from my field tips. I also had WacEm shoot like that.
I have yet to test the terminal performance of the slick tricks, but I would guess they do the trick slickly.
I have yet to test the terminal performance of the slick tricks, but I would guess they do the trick slickly.
Stringmusic
Active Member
Joe Hulburt
Active Member
I tested one on a Roosevelt bull last season. He ran about 40 yards and tipped over backwards! It was a pass thru and the broadhead didn't suffer any damage. They fly straight and seem like a great product to me. Getting ready to order some more for spring bear.
RUTTIN
Veteran member
I think any broadhead that is sharp, and most of all that you have confidence in that you can put it where it needs to be will do just fine. For me I shoot Magnus Stingers.
I'm with RUTTIN. Any sharp broadhead will work as long as you can put it where you need to. Some are definitely more durable than others. I would check for sharpness out of the package and be able to put on final touches. I haven't seen too many that are razor sharp. I check mine by seeing if they will shave hair off my arm.
The last 3 years I've been using the Muzzy MX-4. I have a love hate relationship with them but they do a number on an elk. Big hole, and durable. I believe I've killed two elk with the same broadhead. The hate part is that my bow has to be perfectly tuned for them to fly and group with my field points. Once thats done they fly great.
The last 3 years I've been using the Muzzy MX-4. I have a love hate relationship with them but they do a number on an elk. Big hole, and durable. I believe I've killed two elk with the same broadhead. The hate part is that my bow has to be perfectly tuned for them to fly and group with my field points. Once thats done they fly great.
brooks
Member
The last 2 elk I have killed I used Magnus 100gn Snuffer SS and neither bull made it 40 yards. A good sharp bh is whats needed and there are alot of good ones out there today.
chuffness
New Member
- May 7, 2011
- 39
- 0
Last year I used Innerloc.. Seemed to work pretty good out to 50 ( Possibly just me and my setup )
Never got to test it =(
This year im thinking of trying a The new Ulmer Edge. http://www.trophytaker.com/edge_broadhead.aspx
Anyone seen or tried one of these ?
Never got to test it =(
This year im thinking of trying a The new Ulmer Edge. http://www.trophytaker.com/edge_broadhead.aspx
Anyone seen or tried one of these ?
8750
Active Member
Bitterroot,
What shafts are you using with your Slick Tricks? I am interested in these broadheads, although I was under the assumption that a 4 blade could disrupt the flight by interfference with the fletching. The more I think about it though the 4 blades might just be causing constructive interferrence if the frequency of the waves created by the broadhead add constructively to the frequency of the fletching. Or the broadhead just becomes the rudder instead of the fletching. I am interested how a front guided missile compares to a rear guided? I think the arrow shaft will have a huge influence on the outcome of this affect.
Does anyone out there have access to a wind tunnel? I guess maybe I could make a crude one here at home and run some tests.
What shafts are you using with your Slick Tricks? I am interested in these broadheads, although I was under the assumption that a 4 blade could disrupt the flight by interfference with the fletching. The more I think about it though the 4 blades might just be causing constructive interferrence if the frequency of the waves created by the broadhead add constructively to the frequency of the fletching. Or the broadhead just becomes the rudder instead of the fletching. I am interested how a front guided missile compares to a rear guided? I think the arrow shaft will have a huge influence on the outcome of this affect.
Does anyone out there have access to a wind tunnel? I guess maybe I could make a crude one here at home and run some tests.
What Factors To Consider Before Buying the Best Fixed Blade Broadhead For Elk?
1. Penetration Capability:
For an effective hunting experience, bone-crushing and penetration capacity are the most dependable factors for the broadheads. Hunting will be distressing without these 2 elements. For avoiding deflection, the ?clean cuts? are definitely essential while shooting the target since you do not desire the bolt to jump out of the animal.
2. Flight Trajectory:
No to mention, as described above the big blades are greatly affected by the wind so you must consider this before purchasing. If your nearly all shots are low range as much as 20 ? 40 yards then they are not affected by the wind significantly.
In that factor, Mechanical broadheads provide more straightness. At the time of spinning if the broadhead deflects then you could check out the alignment of broadheads or tune the blades by utilizing spin tester.
3. Sharpness Of The Blades:
The term ?Sharpness? in hunting explains the significance of itself. Not forgetting, you must ask these questions yourself before buying any heads are that: How long the integrity last? How merely may it be sharpened? Do blades remain razor-sharp after a number of shots?
4. The Blood Trails:
The blood trails left behind can be the important consideration. The ?fixed-blades? provide deep penetration however quite low blood trails and for sure, ?mechanical blades? possess a huge benefit over the fixed blades. On the other hand, several fixed blades provide good outcomes in that factor.
Judging by all these 4 factors, we have outlined a few of the great products. By determining your needs you can choose the Best Fixed Blade broadheads for elk which fit your needs more.
source:
1. Penetration Capability:
For an effective hunting experience, bone-crushing and penetration capacity are the most dependable factors for the broadheads. Hunting will be distressing without these 2 elements. For avoiding deflection, the ?clean cuts? are definitely essential while shooting the target since you do not desire the bolt to jump out of the animal.
2. Flight Trajectory:
No to mention, as described above the big blades are greatly affected by the wind so you must consider this before purchasing. If your nearly all shots are low range as much as 20 ? 40 yards then they are not affected by the wind significantly.
In that factor, Mechanical broadheads provide more straightness. At the time of spinning if the broadhead deflects then you could check out the alignment of broadheads or tune the blades by utilizing spin tester.
3. Sharpness Of The Blades:
The term ?Sharpness? in hunting explains the significance of itself. Not forgetting, you must ask these questions yourself before buying any heads are that: How long the integrity last? How merely may it be sharpened? Do blades remain razor-sharp after a number of shots?
4. The Blood Trails:
The blood trails left behind can be the important consideration. The ?fixed-blades? provide deep penetration however quite low blood trails and for sure, ?mechanical blades? possess a huge benefit over the fixed blades. On the other hand, several fixed blades provide good outcomes in that factor.
Judging by all these 4 factors, we have outlined a few of the great products. By determining your needs you can choose the Best Fixed Blade broadheads for elk which fit your needs more.
source:
kgundy212
New Member
Muzzy trocar HB, half fixed half expandable did some serious damage to my white tail last year. So much so that I will be using for my elk hunt this year. It's all about placement however!