We just finished a 3rd (wife's tag) and 4th season (mine) deer hunt on the same unit. After very tough hunting conditions, I nearly left after day three of the 4th season after hunting the one prime day after the snow to no avail. I didn't want any regrets, so I was the last one off the mountain I was hunting the last day of the season (last night). I worked my tail off and am exhausted this morning. Glassed up hundreds of deer. Most large groups of does were being trailed by two year old fork horns and three points. I saw only one seriously rutting buck, a large fork horn, while still hunting through some PJs. That was on Thursday when it was snowing.
In total, we saw one true trophy buck on private and we sat on the does as the came onto public but he was never interested enough to follow. Other than that we saw two 150-160 class bucks, a guy packing out a very nice five point yesterday (last day), and a bunch of 2-3 year old bucks. Groups of 10 to 15 does would have a fork horn, three point or tiny four point following them. Everyone said "you should have been here last year". Everyone I talked to was struggling this year. Goes to show you weather takes precedence over this year's late season dates. Hunting higher may have helped but my research had all been on the lower country.
In the future, even on years with great dates, I think I will lean to a year with a dark moon. The full moon late in the 3rd season combined with the weather made for little happening on evening hunts since the deer weren't moving until last light.