I've shot 7 does in WY, and only one buck when I had the tag. I saw a steady decrease in the antelope numbers since 2015, when the zone that I hunted looked like the Seringetti. I was able to build on my knowledge of the area while gaining points to draw a buck tag again, but now that I have enough to draw, the zone is almost void of antelope. I drove through the unit in Sept., and only saw a few on an alfalfa patch, where I had previously seen hundreds throughout the unit.
I don't feel bad about killing does when I had the tag when the numbers supported it, but even if I could draw some now, I would not. Wild game came not be stockpiled, and harvest can be regulated when the situation requires that. But, these weather or disease events are the real killers and they happen beyond anyone's control.
Make no mistake the increase in NR hunting has really had an impact on pronghorn in many areas. Lots of NR's like you would show up every year and whack multiple does (nothing wrong with that).
The thing is, 10, 15, 20 years ago there were thousands of pronghorn buck and doe tags that were not even being issued. With the popularity of pronghorn hunting, there isn't a single tag that goes unsold now.
I believe the GF has been over-issuing pronghorn tags for decades and got away with those high quotas because the tags never sold out. I used to sometimes buy a leftover buck tag the last day of the season, just to fund the department and had no intention of hunting it.
One herd near my house you could buy 2 buck and 4 doe tags the last day of the season when I moved here, high of 1100 permits available. That unit is now issuing zero doe tags and only 250 buck tags and it takes several points for a NR to draw it. Interestingly enough, 3-8 years ago the draw odds for buck tags was better than doe tags. Very few residents applied for that unit and could be drawn 3rd choice 3 years ago.
That's not a situation of a bad winter, drought, or anything but over-hunting.
This particular area isn't the only one that this has happened to.