Score these mule deer bucks

[D. Robert Franz]

I'm working on a mule deer book and was curious to see what you all might come up with for gross scores on these 4 bucks. These are all huge bodied deer. I know it's tough from a photo but give it a go... Have fun!

 

[NE69]

Ohh man. This will be fun!!!! Thank you and will need to study these for a bit to do this right.

 

[Tim McCoy]

Looks like 4 bucks all named Huge! Either that or there are 5 and one set is comprised of identical twins. They are really easy to score when they are that big if you have a tag in your pocket, just shoot any one and score him up later. Super pictures, thanks for sharing.

 

[Colorado Cowboy]

Looks to me like #2 & #3 are the sane buck. I'd have a hard time passing on any, but......

#2/3 or 5 would be my choices. As to score, I'd say all are near or above 200".

 

[D. Robert Franz]

Looks like 4 bucks all named Huge! Either that or there are 5 and one set is comprised of identical twins. They are really easy to score when they are that big if you have a tag in your pocket, just shoot any one and score him up later. Super pictures, thanks for sharing.

Yes there are 2 photos of the same buck (2&3) to help score them! Two of these bucks exceed 40" wide outside spread IMHO

 

[velvetfvr]

#1 174
#2 206
#3 183
#4 182

I will say this, I would have shoot any of them with my bow.

 

[laxwyo]

2 and 3. Look to be the same buck
#1 183
#2/3 210
#4 194
#5 190

 

[velvetfvr]

2 and 3. Look to be the same buck
#1 183
#2/3 210
#4 194
#5 190

2 and 3 are the same bucks

 

[Ikeepitcold]

Does shoot them all count?! They all score perfect to me.

 

[D. Robert Franz]

I'm going to throw in 2 more bucks.. These are known quantities so I want to see how close you come on these.

 

[ando_31]

1, 191
2, 230
3, 200
4, 195

next set
1, 200
2, 205

 

[laxwyo]

216 and 204

 

[PlainsHunter]

I think they'll all go over 150, maybe 160. Joking. Huge deer, bigger than anything I expect to see on the hoof in my lifetime.

 

[libidilatimmy]

I bet if you add all 6 together, they'll score over 1000"

Beautiful deer for sure!

 

[Cobbhunts]

These are just a great collection of pictures. Thanks for sharing!! Truly amazing, both the bucks and the photo quality.

 

[dead river]

I made a point not to look at the other replies:

1) 192
2/3) 266
3) 212

 

[dead river]

good thing i did not look. i am the high end and would have biased my estimates.... whitetails are easier. , untill you get a non-typical

 

[D. Robert Franz]

I made a point not to look at the other replies:

1) 192
2/3) 266
3) 212

I think you're closer! My 2nd pair of bucks I show give me a reference since they're known scores!

 

[RICMIC]

DR, you're killing me. I start adding up the score and then began to gag before I get to the total. Once I decide it's a shooter, then I don't look at the antlers again until it's all over. WOW!!

 

[Fink]

Good grief. That third picture is incredible.

I wouldn't even know where to begin on score guesses.