My First Crossbow Hunting Experience (WY Elk)

Umpqua Hunter

Veteran member
May 26, 2011
3,576
88
61
North Umpqua, Oregon
I haven't seen much on our forum dealing with crossbows so I thought I would start this thread.

Last fall I injured my left shoulder (an impingement) hanging my elk at the meat locker. When this year's application season rolled by, I had to pass on a long time plan to burn a pile of AZ elk points because there was no way I could be sure I would be able to draw my bow by September, and AZ requires a fairly significant handicap to allow for use of a crossbow. There is also no way to return an AZ tag and get the points reinstated.

We then decided we would burn my oldest son's max elk points and take him to Wyoming. I also put in for WY for what I thought would be a long shot elk tag and I also drew. I decided, if possible, I would like to bow hunt for 7-10 days and then hit the first couple days of the rifle opener on Oct 1. I was in physical therapy most of the spring and the shoulder has been recovering nicely, but I still could not draw my bow by June 1 "deadline". I pushed it to July 1 and did some bow pulling exercises, which my shoulder was not ready for at all. I decided it was time to bite the bullet and order a crossbow. I can pull with my bad shoulder, it just can't handle the load of drawing my bow against it.

Just in case, I had done a lot of research on crossbows and decided to go with an Excalibur Matrix 380 with recurve limbs. Excalibur has a very well done video on the durability and accuracy of their crossbow. With a lot less to go wrong or out of time with recurve limbs compared to a compound type, I decided to go with it. I also don't know of any pro shops in Oregon that would be proficient with a crossbow, so simplicity and reliability and that I could maintain my own weapon was super important to me. I also wanted one I could easily maintain on the mountain. Here is the Excalibur video I spoke of.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tWQ7e6WipGU

The theory makes a lot of sense. Compound is a definite advantage when you are shooting a bow and having to hold the draw weight. When using a crossbow (which holds the bow drawn) recurve limbs make a lot of sense since there is far less to go wrong.

I will be shooting a 250 grain arrow with a 150 grain Slick Trick STX (crossbow broadhead). Kinetic energy should be around 110 ft. lbs.

Hopefully this will also open the door for my wife to burn her WY elk points in the next couple years for an archery season and kill her first bull.

I am still an amateur so any advice is welcome.
 

Ikeepitcold

Administrator
Staff member
Feb 22, 2011
10,026
1,612
Reno Nv
Interesting. I would assume that Wy is the same as Nv in the laws regarding using crossbows, only allowed during rifle season wich is any legal weapon. I've also thought of getting a cross bow just to have one and maybe use it for coyote hunting just to change things up. I think having a shoulder injury a crossbow would def be the way to go for you and if you where unable to get it done you could always use a rifle as a back up.
I haven't really did much research on crossbows but I do agree with you in your choice.
 

ssliger

Very Active Member
Mar 9, 2011
900
0
Laramie WY
Crossbows are allowed during archery in Wyoming. I don't know anything about them though. My uncle hunts with one due to having a bum shoulder.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
Jan 7, 2013
129
0
central Kentucky
This was my first crossbow kill (4 or 5) years ago. Our archery season in ky is split. Some parts cross bows are allowed and some parts of the season only traditional and compound bows are legal.
I think my crossbow gives an advantage over my compound but the harvest statistics statewide don't indicate much difference.



Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 

Umpqua Hunter

Veteran member
May 26, 2011
3,576
88
61
North Umpqua, Oregon
That sucks you hurt your shoulder. I have a question, what bow do you have now?
Velvet I am still shooting a Matthews Switchback XT. I can draw my wife's Matthews (about 35 pound pull) now which was uber painful earlier this year.

IKIC, as ssliger said, crossbows are legal in archery seasons in WY.
 

missjordan

Veteran member
Dec 9, 2014
1,136
22
Missoula, MT
Sorry to hear about your shoulder, I've had some problems as well that have kept me from shooting as much as I'd like to. I bought a new compound last year and sold it because it bothered my shoulder to shoot it. So I pulled my diamond rzr edge back out of storage for the year, I figured next year I'd be in the.market for a new one so well see what happens
 

Silentstalker

Active Member
Oct 26, 2013
195
22
Utah
I have a Parker Gale Force crossbow that is really fun to shoot! Im a bowhunter through and through but I have to admit they are fun to shoot! My Wife and son both shot antelope in Wyoming with it a couple years ago.

My suggestion would be to get a good set of shooting sticks and look for places you can hunt from a stand or blind. Carrying a crossbow is less fun than a bow. Sitting on sticks, they are incredibly accurate! Also shoot a lot so you get accustomed at different distances and pack an extra string just in case.

ImageUploadedByTapatalk1436414764.176006.jpg
 

velvetfvr

Veteran member
May 6, 2012
2,026
0
Nv
Velvet I am still shooting a Matthews Switchback XT. I can draw my wife's Matthews (about 35 pound pull) now which was uber painful earlier this year.

IKIC, as ssliger said, crossbows are legal in archery seasons in WY.
Ah that's actually what I've heard is one of the better Mathews. But honestly if it was me, I'd also look into a new bow like an elite, expedition, obsession, new breed and prime. Or maybe the new bowtechs. Somethin you can make a higher let off with a more generous valley. Somethin that can help the agin joints and that shoulder. But I'd try them first. Heck maybe a 50lb 355+ fps bow could be an option also since you'd only pull 50lbs.
 

CrossCreeks

Veteran member
Mar 6, 2014
1,023
0
Dover, Tennessee
I have a Parker Crossbow in addition to a compound bow, I really love the Crossbow as it is deadly accurate. I have been thinking about using it on a upcoming antelope hunt in Wyoming. I know some people frown on crossbows as not being as sporting as compounds or recurve bows but I think they are great alternative for hunting and are great for someone who wants to hunt and have problems with a shooting a regular compound bow. What I have seen, read and heard about the Excalibur is a great crossbow and is almost indestructible ! Good choice and good luck, go stick a big one !