Your Biggest Buck
- Thread starter ScottR
- Start date
Montana
Veteran member
Timber Stalker
Active Member
- May 22, 2020
- 292
- 623
I wasn’t the hunter, just helping. this was the biggest buck I’ve ever been a part of. Grossed over 180
Well after much teasing here is a trophy shot, this buck was without a doubt the biggest bodied deer I have ever laid hands on. My 2013 buck was big, this one made him look average...
mallardsx2
Veteran member
- Jul 8, 2015
- 3,819
- 3,016
Have you read Mike’s books on field judging them? Really makes it simple, the hardest bucks to judge have no outstanding features.
Yes been reading them its just nice to practice on pics and bucks when its a known score to see if I got close. ( I think a pic thread with a way to hide the score till your ready to see it would be a lot of fun.)
My best just over 200” gross.
Also a 198” whitetail that grew forks on some points and has a 24” inside spread. He had some muley traits but it’s a 3 hour drive to the closest muleys.
Also a 198” whitetail that grew forks on some points and has a 24” inside spread. He had some muley traits but it’s a 3 hour drive to the closest muleys.
Hilltop
Veteran member
I have an official score on the non typical at the start of the thread if you want to practice.
Here are a few simple box framing type of judging things that help to judge quick if a buck is actually big, then pick apart. I can do this pretty quickly and then I get into the rack bracketing that Mike uses to really break the bucks down.
Big deer look big, look for the big buck head bob, the giants almost look cartoonish when they walk.
If the fronts are as tall as the backs, pay attention! Generally speaking, that is a mature deer with good fronts, look at all the bucks in this thread for reference.
Frame is everything, fronts as tall as the backs and wider than the ears generally is a buck to pay attention to.
An easy way to judge mass is measure the bases against the base of the ears. Then measure it all relative to that.
Mass hides inches and from there it is just a matter of adding up the points and main beam length.
Big deer look big, look for the big buck head bob, the giants almost look cartoonish when they walk.
If the fronts are as tall as the backs, pay attention! Generally speaking, that is a mature deer with good fronts, look at all the bucks in this thread for reference.
Frame is everything, fronts as tall as the backs and wider than the ears generally is a buck to pay attention to.
An easy way to judge mass is measure the bases against the base of the ears. Then measure it all relative to that.
Mass hides inches and from there it is just a matter of adding up the points and main beam length.
Some of the toughest bucks of any species to score have no exceptional features, but are not weak anywhere. I shot a 9 point whitetail last year that fit this description. He had decent width, mass, and length of beam and points but wasn’t exceptional anywhere. Nothing stood out to judge the rest from. I guessed him around 150” and he ended up being 162”. He had an awesome 8pt frame plus a 3” 9th point. I remember Mike Eastman talking about muleys like that in his book. Easy deer to overlook.
WOW great deer Scott. Doing a shoulder mount or full body mountWell after much teasing here is a trophy shot, this buck was without a doubt the biggest bodied deer I have ever laid hands on. My 2013 buck was big, this one made him look average...
It's a whitetail not a big score, but at this point it's my first and only buck so far and I am still very proud of it. Picture of the grip and grin I'd have to pull up on the files somewhere on the computer or hard drive.
hunter25
Very Active Member
I think my 2 best along with my sons.
His is the second picture
His is the second picture
Hilltop
Veteran member
Hunter25, that neck and body on your son's deer is awesome. Talk about a pig!