US Wildlife Workers Plead guilty to poaching-related charges

SunnyInCO

Member
Oct 20, 2015
101
2
Highlands Ranch, Colorado
Very disturbing article especially if they are still employed by the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service as the article states.

https://www.washingtonpost.com/national/energy-environment/us-wildlife-workers-plead-guilty-to-poaching-related-charges/2016/07/12/f1773ff6-489e-11e6-8dac-0c6e4accc5b1_story.html#comments

DENVER — Two U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service employees pleaded guilty to poaching-related charges in the killing of a trophy-class bull elk in western Colorado, state officials said Tuesday.

Thad Bingham, 44, and Brian Scheer, 45, pleaded guilty to trespassing on private land that was closed to hunting at the time of the 2014 incident, Colorado Parks and Wildlife spokesman Mike Porras said.

Bingham also pleaded guilty to illegal wildlife possession, the state said. Bingham shot the animal with a bow and arrow, Porras said. Scheer and two other men — who didn’t work for the federal agency — were along on the hunt, he said.

The investigation began after Bingham posted a photo of himself with the elk online, and state officers could tell from the image that the area was off-limits to hunting, officials said.

Investigators obtained warrants to search a federal fish hatchery where Bingham and Scheer work as well as Bingham’s home. Officers recovered the elk’s antlers at Bingham’s home, Porras said.

No phone number could be found for Bingham or Scheer. Both live in Fruita.

Fish and Wildlife Service spokeswoman Anna Munoz said both men still work for the agency, but she couldn’t comment on whether the service took any action against them.

“Poachers come from all walks of life, but everyone is subject to the same rules and regulations,” said JT Romatzke, a Colorado Parks and Wildlife area wildlife manager.

State officials identified the other two men on the hunt as Josh Fitzsimmons, 45, of Rifle and Barrett Rowles, 48 of Collbran. Both pleaded guilty to trespassing, the state said.

Fitzsimmons didn’t immediately return a phone message. No number could be found for Rowles.

Bingham was fined $200 and ordered to donate $5,000 to the Rocky Mountain Elk Foundation. The other three were fined $86 each.

They could also lose their Colorado hunting and fishing privileges for five years after a review by a hearing officer.
 

shootbrownelk

Veteran member
Apr 11, 2011
1,535
196
Wyoming
Our Government employees at work! Trespassing/Poaching/Wanton waste. They'll probably be inline for a promotion. If they aren't fired now, they sure as hell should be. And what a pittance of a fine!
 

Extractor

Active Member
Jun 7, 2015
351
93
Appleton, Wisconsin
FBI Director Comey personally investigated this case. He determined all those involved were guilty by a preponderence of the evidence, he then noted all 4 men were nephews of Hillary Clinton, and they hadn't intended to do anything wrong they were just confused by technology. Besides he stated "What differnce does it make now". All 4 men have now been promoted and received commendations for their heroic efforts.

Not to far-fetched.
 

shootbrownelk

Veteran member
Apr 11, 2011
1,535
196
Wyoming
Unless I read it wrong they have to pay 5000 to RMEF.
How much is a trophy elk hunt on private land going for these days? That "donation" to RMEF was not a fine. Punishment doesn't fit the crime....and these thieves are Federal F&W employees? They should be job hunting IMO.
 

brianboh

Active Member
Jun 4, 2015
396
1
Powell, Wyoming
I agree that 200 is not steep enough but he is required to pay 5200 whether you want to call it a donation or a fine he is still out 5200. Now it depends on what his position is within the USFW if he needs to be job hunting. If he is in LE maybe. I hate to see someone's life destroyed over killing an elk. However he did know what he was doing. Hell to me not being able to hunt for 5 years is a hell of a penalty. The fines are also city/county specific. If people are not happy with the fine they should argue that with the local government. It is possible that if he was in the next county the "Fine" could have been 20 times higher. He already is paying more then what a person convicted with a DUI is and IMO that is much much worse then shooting an elk.
 

ivorytip

Veteran member
Mar 24, 2012
3,768
50
44
SE Idaho
Brian, I see what you are saying but you cant compare a DUI to poaching an elk, and a trophy class elk at that. not only did he poach and are federal employees, the made it impossible for law abiding hunters to peruse this animal. they (federal employees) stole from the state and from everyone that's ever paid to hunt there. you are right, years of not being able to hunt is a to the gut and the $5200 is a fair price. however, federal employees should be held to a higher standards as far as jobs go.
 

swampokie

Veteran member
Jul 29, 2013
1,166
93
46
Haworth Oklahoma
FBI Director Comey personally investigated this case. He determined all those involved were guilty by a preponderence of the evidence, he then noted all 4 men were nephews of Hillary Clinton, and they hadn't intended to do anything wrong they were just confused by technology. Besides he stated "What differnce does it make now". All 4 men have now been promoted and received commendations for their heroic efforts.
This may be the best one I've heard in my life!
Not to far-fetched.
this is amazing! And true!
 

swampokie

Veteran member
Jul 29, 2013
1,166
93
46
Haworth Oklahoma
One thing i must ask. If a man gates and posts public property and kills an animal behimd the gate on public property is he also considered a poacher?
 

Wyoming Hart

Very Active Member
Oct 10, 2014
853
163
Spring Run, PA
One thing i must ask. If a man gates and posts public property and kills an animal behimd the gate on public property is he also considered a poacher?
I wouldn't call him a poacher, if the harvest of the animal is done legally, but he is doing an illegal act by posting and gating public property.