I just went through that process. I ended up deciding the first thing I needed to decide was how far will I shoot, then find a scope from there. I decided to extend my range 50%, out to 600 or so. Since I have no desire to shoot 800-1200 yards, even at targets, I found a Vortex Viper 4x16 HS LR on sale for $380 at Cabelas, and bought it. I can practice at the range to 600, getmit dialed in and hunt. Don't plan to shoot 100 round matches etc. If I like the LR dial, want a higher grade scope, I can always sell it and upgrade.
There are bunches of reviews out there and you can spend close to 4k on a scope. But for my intended use this made sense to me. The Leupold 4x14 CDS VX III is reasonably priced with good reviews. Had I decided to spend more, the Nightforce SHV would have been on my short list. I did not seriously consider the Huskemaw, not sure why. My plan it to use it as I normally would to 400, and only dial or use the reticle hash marks over 400 if that becomes absolutely necessary. My rifle should be here in 3 weeks, so I have no first hand experience at this time.