2023 draw

kidoggy

Veteran member
Apr 23, 2016
9,855
10,860
57
idaho
have grown weary of chasing the impossible to draw bull or buck tags.
I simply put in for high odds doe /cow tags this year (not even real hunting IMHO) and if I don't draw, I will not even bother donating to the F&G, but instead save my money and simply buy a beef.
sick of the bullshit!
 
  • Like
Reactions: Ikeepitcold

Ikeepitcold

Administrator
Staff member
Feb 22, 2011
9,955
1,528
Reno Nv
It’s getting tough out there no doubt. Years ago we would buy OTC bull tags and have weeks to decide if we wanted them or not but these days you better be ready as soon as it opens or they are all gone!
Idaho has changed a lot in the last few years.
 

JimP

Administrator
Mar 28, 2016
7,232
8,543
71
Gypsum, Co
Funny how things change as you age.

I've got a few tags that I'll chase until they throw dirt in my face but most of them I just put in for the ones that I know that I'll draw, but even those are getting harder to draw. That's the big problem when you have the number of hunters who want to hunt a animal and fewer animals to hunt.

On the beef, have you priced out a half a beef lately, and I'm not talking about having a friend sell you one on the cheap.
 

kidoggy

Veteran member
Apr 23, 2016
9,855
10,860
57
idaho
The last one that I got a number of years ago was around $1600 cut and wrapped. Now I believe that it is on the other side of $2000
last one I did, in 2021 was 2 grand for the whole beef. so, I would expect it might be a few hundred more, now.

getting pretty spendy, but what isn't?

"LET'S GO BRANDON!"
 

Muley bound

Active Member
Mar 12, 2013
392
601
Wisconsin
This is the first year in a while that I’m not even putting in for a controlled hunt in Idaho. I drew my general Montana deer tag, finally. So, even though I could pay the fees to try and draw a tag, I’m not going to. Next year, I’ll TRY and get in line on the internet and buy my general tag, which I’ll prolly get a “server is backed up” reply and then I’ll apply for a controlled hunt. That’s next years problem
 

RICMIC

Veteran member
Feb 21, 2012
2,008
1,783
Two Harbors, Minnesota
OTC as a resident doesn't hurt too bad, but even a general draw tag as a NR will usually end up costing more than buying beef. My recent tags in WY came to $727 for GEN elk, plus $208 for the points; $303 for the cow tag; $21.50 Conservation license; $75 archery lic. Total - $1334
Add 6,000 miles of driving and other expenses. I did fill both tags, but have been on a number of other hunts where I did not, so most of us clearly do not hunt just to feed ourselves.
 
  • Like
Reactions: kidoggy

JimP

Administrator
Mar 28, 2016
7,232
8,543
71
Gypsum, Co
I realized many years ago that hunting in other states is not for those who want to save money over just buying beef or pork.

One friend questioned me about the amount of meat that I get off of a javelina vs what it cost for the tag and to travel the 2000 miles round trip. I just told him that if you need to justify the cost then perhaps you shouldn't be hunting, even locally. I do it for the enjoyment and the fun of hunting a animal that we don't have locally. Even for my elk and deer hunts out of state it is mostly for the enjoyment of getting out with friends and meeting others.

Now if you want to really compare cost vs return you need to book a hunt over in Africa. Then all the numbers can be thrown out of the window at 30,000 feet as you fly across the Atlantic Ocean.
 

kidoggy

Veteran member
Apr 23, 2016
9,855
10,860
57
idaho
welp, drew nothing once again. thank GOD I have mastered a delicious tag soup!
just kidding. seeing if anyone is paying attention. :D

I actually put in for an elk hunt I don't even want to go on, trying to up my chances of drawing anything.;) doubt it will work either.
 
  • Like
Reactions: D_Dubya

kidoggy

Veteran member
Apr 23, 2016
9,855
10,860
57
idaho
That makes these guys reasonable.....if I didn't have multiple elk in the freezer I would be tempted. May get a pig one of these days though.
yeah. this is the first year in many my freezer has been empty. I seldom draw a hunt, but I have been pretty successful in the general hunts most years. I am just getting tired of the shitshows of the general hunts. I simply don't look forward to it as I did in my youth. I have gotten to the point if I can't get a draw hunt, I don't even bother to go anymore. or if I do it is only for a day trip.
most of my "trophies " collect dust or have been given away. so really, the meat is the only reason I even bother anymore.
for the past 20 years or so, I have enjoyed bringing the youngsters and guiding them. I would rather see them fill their tags than kill one myself. I believe I have gotten to the point that buying beef or pork just makes more sense. unless I can draw one of the great hunts. think I am going to split a beef with my brother this year and probably get a pig next.
he has been trying to get me to go to Alaska with him for years for a fishing trip, but I really have no desire for that either. I would rather just take my fly rod and travel 15 minutes and catch 14 - 20-inch trout all day long. trolling on the ocean just doesn't really sound like much fun to me.
 
  • Like
Reactions: tdub24

kidoggy

Veteran member
Apr 23, 2016
9,855
10,860
57
idaho
2023 deer season I went out killed a deer/doe by 9 a.m was back in town by about 10:30. showered by noon. and butchered the next day. then ended up giving the entire thing to a friend who hit hard times. I guess being able to do such is why I continue to hunt these days.
 
  • Like
Reactions: tdub24

Mr Drysdale

Active Member
Mar 24, 2013
433
327
I have been able to draw different tags in different states in the past. Have hunted Elk in Utah and deer in Wyoming and Montana. I loved the experience of hunting the West and meeting the different people. I am from Mississippi where we have probably the most liberal hunting rules. Of course there is only Whitetails to hunt. Bow season opens the first of October and either bow or gun is then open until January 31st. As I am currently employed full time I hunt the weekends. All of them except for Sunday morning church. Our license allows a hunter to take three bucks and three does plus an additional two does if taken with a bow. I haven’t killed a buck in the past few years as I generally scout for my four grandchildren. I will take a couple of does with my bow for the freezer and to carry to Talladega. I would like to hunt out West a few more times but I don’t have the fortitude to play the point game. I am retiring at the end of the year and plan on spending much more time in the Mississippi woods. Good Luck to all who apply!
 
  • Like
Reactions: kidoggy