Traditional vs compound

IDELKFVR

Active Member
Dec 15, 2013
271
0
EMMETT,IDAHO
Sold my compound bow last year and was thinking about getting back into archery hunting but using traditional equipment ( recurve ). Mentioned this to a guy i work with that hunts with compound bow and is very good with it has killed elk the last four or five years with it.he stated that i wouldnt be allowed to hunt in his camp because traditional equipment is not ethical enough. I ask him if he ever heard of fred bear. I also reminded him out of those five or so years he has hit and lost a couple of elk. Just thought i would throw this out for conversation.
 

Gr8bawana

Veteran member
Aug 14, 2014
2,670
604
Nevada
He doesn't sound like much of a friend. He has the same attitude that some fly fishermen have against those that use bait for fishing and look down their noses at us.
But then again it's the same attitude I have towards those that want to use crossbow during archery season. :confused:
 

Steve O

Member
Apr 26, 2012
92
37
Michigan
My friends who hunt with stickbows outnumber my friends that hunt with compounds 25:1. They've killed every animal in North America from Antelope to Polar Bear. All 29 species when you put the guys and gals together. Your friend is sadly painting with a broad brush and is fairly ignorant.

I'll put my ethics up against anyone and I've not shot a compound in 15 years. Ethics has NOTHING to do with the bow.


DIY Longbow bull of mine:

 

Steve O

Member
Apr 26, 2012
92
37
Michigan
That bow was a Super Shrew; short hybrid longbow. I've grown out of my short bow phase! Bull was 361 gross, I'll not do better.
 

Badgerstate36

New Member
Nov 9, 2015
5
0
Columbus, OH
Traditional archery equipment isnt ethical? Ummm...what? Sure, modern compound bows make it easier because they give you more range but come on, any skilled bowhunter could be just as effective with either.
 

buckbull

Veteran member
Jun 20, 2011
2,166
1,353
Its not the hunting tool itself that has ethics; its the situations hunters use them in that creates an ethical situation.