Possible "For Sale" section

Would you like to see a Classified/For Sale section?

  • Yes

    Votes: 34 89.5%
  • No

    Votes: 4 10.5%

  • Total voters
    38

Bitterroot Bulls

Veteran member
Apr 25, 2011
2,326
0
Montana
I love the idea.

However, you wouldn't want people signing up to just hock their wares. So maybe a 50 post minimum before you are allowed to post something for sale. Also other rules, like no commercial business, no spamming, etc.
 

Brocka

Member
Jan 11, 2012
92
0
Enumclaw, Washington
Great idea on a "post minimum". I think it would help out the younger crowd on getting started on a few of the more expensive things! Also I would agree with the no commercial use & spam.
 

Ikeepitcold

Administrator
Staff member
Feb 22, 2011
10,103
1,741
Reno Nv
Is there a way a moderator could set up a pole with a brief list of rules?
I think you can set up a poll. There is another one running now on another thread. As far as the moderator he's tough to get ahold of. I'm assuming it's due to the show season rite now and he is very busy.
 

wolftalonID

Very Active Member
Mar 10, 2011
679
0
Idaho
Keep in mind why Eastmans has chosen to not to a BST section. It has been proven by forum moderators not just here but other forums as well, myself included in the history of moderation of forums, that BST sections are a liability beyond reason. Its tough to moderate, and one mans idea of a well taken care of item is another mans pile of crap, and vise versa.
When one well known member sells an item to another well known member and a disagreement ensues, staff will have a near impossible choice to make when it comes to involving themselves in the mediation.
Also some companies in the past have been drawn into legal action over BST forums that is costly and avoidable.
Being Eastmans is a worldwide forum, its much easier to use places that are more local to you where you can see your item in person prior to a money exchange. Such places like online classifieds and craigslist, ect.
Much safer for the both parties and alleviates the liability of Eastmans on a deal that could be sour.

Dont mistake this insight for what it is not, as I myself have done well with BST sections in the past on other sites. I just have had to deal with moderating sour deals one too many times as well.

If Eastmans is to do this, I would recommend, a minimum post, as well as a time active on the forum minimum prior to allowance into the BST club. 200 post minimum and 6 months active posting.
A forum moderator controlled access forum with a consensus of the currently allowed BST members. Like a vote to allow a new club member. This would allow those in the club a chance to review posts and forum attitude of possible new members prior to them coming on board.
A feed back required for every deal for others to review.
Its an idea but one that takes full time moderation to handle.
It would take an internet geek to hang out here......
anyone know a candidate?
 

BobT

Active Member
Dec 1, 2011
263
0
Missouri Ozarks
I voted yes, I'm new here but belong to a bunch of other forums, most of them have BST sections. I fully support minimum post counts and or minimum length of membership. I don't think a 200 post count is reasonable though, I try not to post unless I have something I think is helpful to say and may never get to 200 posts. I'm pretty new to the DIY western hunting scene so I'm mostly here to learn, I don't really have a lot to offer on most of the subjects as a noob so I subscribe to the "better to remain silent and thought a fool than to speak up and remove all doubt" theory .

Bob
 

jenbickel

Veteran member
Feb 22, 2011
1,064
1
37
Sheridan, Wyoming
www.facebook.com
If Eastmans is to do this, I would recommend, a minimum post, as well as a time active on the forum minimum prior to allowance into the BST club. 200 post minimum and 6 months active posting.
A forum moderator controlled access forum with a consensus of the currently allowed BST members. Like a vote to allow a new club member. This would allow those in the club a chance to review posts and forum attitude of possible new members prior to them coming on board.
A feed back required for every deal for others to review.
Its an idea but one that takes full time moderation to handle.
It would take an internet geek to hang out here......
anyone know a candidate?
I definitely agree on there being a minimum amount of posts you have to do before you can post on it.
I would totally be a full time moderator.. I have no life... and I'm smarter than your average bear... and I'm on here almost constantly anyways..lol
 

buckbull

Veteran member
Jun 20, 2011
2,182
1,373
I definitely agree on there being a minimum amount of posts you have to do before you can post on it.
I would totally be a full time moderator.. I have no life... and I'm smarter than your average bear... and I'm on here almost constantly anyways..lol
Something ain't right with those Wyoming boys if there's a woman who likes to hunt and has no life.