I lived in AZ for 22 years and enjoyed my time all around that state. I spent years in Prescott, Flagstaff, Tucson, and Phoenix, so I have a good idea of the cities in AZ. I do know, that Payson would rank high on my list if I wanted to return to AZ. Flagstaff was great too, but it is a college town that might be a bit too much for retirement. Payson still has a small town feel (compared to Prescott or Flagstaff), is high elevation up in the pines, and has phenomenal camping/hunting opps. It is growing for sure, and has a lot of tourists and Phoenix folks dropping in on the weekends, but that's just to be expected. I have spent a lot of time around there, mainly elk and squirrel hunting, fishing, hiking, skiing, and camping. It's safe to say that mule deer can be found there, but the immediate areas aren't really known for world-class mule deer hunting like the Kiabab or the Strip. That's not a bad thing since you'll actually be able to draw a tag, but it depends on your standards. I am unsure of exact draw odds or success, but those could easily be found on AZGFD's website. I must say that the elk hunting around there can be pretty impressive, so make sure to start putting in for that IMMEDIATELY! Also, if you enjoy fishing, make sure to stop by Chevelon Canyon- it's a remote gem of a place.