Colorado Early Season High Country Mule Deer

Work2hunt

Veteran member
Mar 2, 2013
1,366
11
St. Louis, MO
Hi Guys,
I have been dreaming of this hunt for a very long time. I'm at 10 points and am trying to decide if and where I should apply for a Colorado mule deer early season rifle hunt. My hunting partener in this endeavor and I are looking to complete this hunt this year or next or maybe we should wait a little longer.

I would virtually be guaranteed to hunt any of the early season high country hunts except for 74 and 82 (82, 86, 861). It appears we are caught in the point chase for these hunts. Due to our number of points we have been looking at 12 (12, 24, 25, 26, 231), 36, 43, 48 (48, 46, 481, 561), 74, and 82 (82, 86, 861). However, unit 12 we can't seem to get any good info on and Colorado's website hasn't had any updated harvest info since 2009. Not sure what that is about.

I'm relatively new to mule deer hunting so judging mule deer is still hard for me. They all look big next to a whitetail:), but I'm thinikning my goal is a 160+ buck whichever unit I hunt (should be doable????). My hunting partener and I are perfectly fine with the high altitude and extreme terrain some of these hunts offer (which is why we are investigating these hunts) plus we like early season not effecting other commitments we have in October and November. We will be doing the hunt DIY and probably not scouting much before the week before the opener. We plan to show up 4 or 5 days early to scout and get acclimated.

I have a couple follow-up calls into the local biologists and game wardens to discuss some of there latest information (winter conditions, herd conditions, etc), but I'm sure they are busy with this being application time. I've previously had conversations with most of them, except for unit 12 (can't get anyone to call back).

I thought I would throw it out there to see where you guys would recommend I apply for and if I should apply this year or next or wait a few more years. I know areas like 43 and 36 are still recovering from the 07-08 winter. Any feedback on realistic buck expectations (is a 160 class buck to small to big???), what the terrain looks like (pics would be great), or unit conditions would be appreciated.
 
Last edited:

RockChucker30

Active Member
Feb 22, 2014
162
0
Tennessee
Are you rifle or bowhunting? You say you're comfortable with the terrain and altitude....how comfortable? Have you done high country hunts before? Do you plan to backpack in or truck camp?
 

woodtick

Veteran member
Feb 24, 2011
1,492
0
Jim Bridger County, Utah
I'm at 10 points also and have really contemplated the 74 hunt several times, I just like the looks of that country!! I don't have much for help it's been ten years since I hunted Colorado.
Boone and Crockett Entrys from 2008-2013, I'd be willing to be a majority of these deer are killed on the late hunts but It'll give ya an idea of quality.

1. Colorado Eagle County, CO typical mule deer 7

2. Colorado La Plata County, CO typical mule deer 6

3. Colorado Delta County, CO typical mule deer 5

4. Colorado Douglas County, CO typical mule deer 5

5. Colorado Garfield County, CO typical mule deer 5

6. Colorado Montezuma County, CO typical mule deer 5

7. Colorado Montrose County, CO typical mule deer 5

8. Colorado Archuleta County, CO typical mule deer 4

9. Colorado Grand County, CO typical mule deer 4

10. Colorado Jefferson County, CO typical mule deer 4

11. Colorado Las Animas County, CO typical mule deer 4

12. Colorado Mesa County, CO typical mule deer 4

13. Colorado Moffat County, CO typical mule deer 4

14. Colorado Rio Blanco County, CO typical mule deer 4

15. Colorado Conejos County, CO typical mule deer 3

16. Colorado El Paso County, CO typical mule deer 2

17. Colorado Pueblo County, CO typical mule deer 2

18. Colorado Rio Grande County, CO typical mule deer 2
 

Musket Man

Veteran member
Jul 20, 2011
6,457
0
colfax, wa
I would take 43 off your list. IMO its over rated and not worth the points. I ML hunted it once and wasnt very impressed. Its beautiful country and I had a great hunt but I would have been very disappointed if I had burned the points the rifle tag takes. Lots of hikers and not alot of deer. Definitely look into how many hikers and recreational use any of the early rifle hunts get as it can really be a problem in some areas. I dont know anything about any of the other units.
 

Work2hunt

Veteran member
Mar 2, 2013
1,366
11
St. Louis, MO
I'm at 10 points also and have really contemplated the 74 hunt several times, I just like the looks of that country!! I don't have much for help it's been ten years since I hunted Colorado.
Boone and Crockett Entrys from 2008-2013, I'd be willing to be a majority of these deer are killed on the late hunts but It'll give ya an idea of quality.

1. Colorado Eagle County, CO typical mule deer 7

2. Colorado La Plata County, CO typical mule deer 6

3. Colorado Delta County, CO typical mule deer 5

4. Colorado Douglas County, CO typical mule deer 5

5. Colorado Garfield County, CO typical mule deer 5

6. Colorado Montezuma County, CO typical mule deer 5

7. Colorado Montrose County, CO typical mule deer 5

8. Colorado Archuleta County, CO typical mule deer 4

9. Colorado Grand County, CO typical mule deer 4

10. Colorado Jefferson County, CO typical mule deer 4

11. Colorado Las Animas County, CO typical mule deer 4

12. Colorado Mesa County, CO typical mule deer 4

13. Colorado Moffat County, CO typical mule deer 4

14. Colorado Rio Blanco County, CO typical mule deer 4

15. Colorado Conejos County, CO typical mule deer 3

16. Colorado El Paso County, CO typical mule deer 2

17. Colorado Pueblo County, CO typical mule deer 2

18. Colorado Rio Grande County, CO typical mule deer 2
Thanks Tick,
I don't have readily available access to Boone and Crocket or Pope and Young records and should probably get it. What are the numbers on the far right of each row? Right now 10 sort of seems like no mans land. 74 and 82 both jumped like 3 points this year. I'm afraid if I keep waiting I might never get to hunt it if points keep jumping like that each year.
 

woodtick

Veteran member
Feb 24, 2011
1,492
0
Jim Bridger County, Utah
Thanks Tick,
I don't have readily available access to Boone and Crocket or Pope and Young records and should probably get it. What are the numbers on the far right of each row? Right now 10 sort of seems like no mans land. 74 and 82 both jumped like 3 points this year. I'm afraid if I keep waiting I might never get to hunt it if points keep jumping like that each year.
Each number signifies the amount of deer that made the record books. I'd look into the flat tops wilderness hunt too.
 

Ridgerunner

Active Member
Feb 21, 2011
308
0
160 should be doable in any if those units, I'm a couple points behind you but doing the same research, I personally think 74 will come back down this year in points required. 43 seems to get mixed reviews, 74 and 82 are known great hunts but things are pretty quiet regarding the other units for sure.
 
Last edited:

eye in sky

Active Member
Mar 4, 2011
213
36
Conifer, Colorado
One thing to keep in mind is this winters snow fall. I plan on doing the early season rifle hunt this year too. I'm waiting till the last moment to put my app in. There has been a lot of snow in the mountains and I've heard some winter range has been affected.
 

tim81212

New Member
Jan 23, 2014
40
0
Canon City, CO
The entire state is over 100% snow pack this year. Some as high as 133%. I should draw 55 second season but by the looks of the B&C numbers maybee I should have waited?