Another Option:I have a pair of Alico Summit Mountain Hiking boots that I bought last year from STP. These are definitely old school. Heavy one piece leather construction, sheepskin lined, Vibram soles, and the obligatory crappy insoles. No rubber toes, etc.. Just HD leather, hand stitching and impeccable Italian craftsmanship. It takes a good bit of walking and frequent applications of Sno-Seal to get them broken in to your feet. I almost gave up on them as too uncomfortable because of their stiffness, but I am glad that I did not. You will need one, or two, pairs of good insoles (Super Feet, etc.), and decent socks. By varying the insole/sock combinations, you can find the fit that is perfect for you. There were not advertised as either waterproof, or insulated, but they are surprisingly warm and do not leak. If you have a problem with the boots squeaking, be sure to get some Sno-Seal on the gussets and padded collar. Great boots at a great price.