That is a false statement. Straight from Berger. Vld hunting bullets like to jump ALOT
Doc... I didn't post my thoughts on that when Bigshot posted it because the reality is it totally depends on your gun. A careful reading of Berger's actual thoughts on seating depth reveals something in between what bigshot and you have said. It is true that in some guns Beger bullets MAY like to "Jump ALOT". Then again they may shoot really well with a small jam as well. Here is a link to the article from Berger, for anyone interested to read:
http://02b0516.netsolhost.com/blog1/?p=43
If you notice the two different starting points, one is with a .010 Jam (target bullet) the other is a .010 jump (hunting bullet). As I read it, the difference in starting point is primarily that in a hunting round the bullet needs to feed well in all kinds of factory guns (Bigshot's original point), and that a "pulled bullet" isn't acceptable in a hunting situation. So for a hunting bullet the starting point is OFF the lands. My gun would feed perfectly fine with a slight jam, Big's may not.
As outlined in the article, there will be a "Sweet Spot" relative to seating depth at which any particular gun will shoot best. That Sweet Spot, according to Berger, is .030-.040 wide (tolerance) so going through their process will give the shooter the correct seating depth for any given gun. In this regard Berger states the following: "This sweet spot is a band .030 to .040 wide and is located anywhere between
jamming the bullets into the lands and .150
jump off the lands." That would seem to me to indicate something of a compromise between your assertion that VLD's like to "Jump ALOT" and Big's that they "shoot best when seated long". Either one may OR may not be true.
In any case, going through the process Berger recommends will clear that up for anyone shooting the VLDs...for THEIR gun. My Kimber at least shot well with .010 jump (at least with Retumbo, that would likely change with powder changes or charge changes). I normally shoot several powders for accuracy and velocity then pick the one I am satisfied with. Once I choose powder, I play with seating depth to dial it in. If all is well at that point, I call it "time to go hunting".
