Problem solved guys...got it figured out.
For future notice, when you put ellipsis at the end of a thread title (...), you can only have three. Once you go over three, it breaks the code and that's what was causing none of us to see the second page without using the carrot tab. The bug report had already been submitted to them, so they will probably patch it and fix it on the next update.
If you ever encounter anything funny like this, make sure you let me know.